The Hull Thread
Chronology of Events From October 1997 - December 1997
=================================================================
October 1, 1997 The Press Enterprise
Federal investigators improperly seized phone records of a leading critic
of the TWA 800 crash probe, a U.S. Justice Department spokesman said Wednesday.
But now Attorney General Janet Reno has given her blessing to a new subpoena
seeking a second batch of records from freelance journalist James Sanders.
The new demand for phone records indicates the investigation is continuing
into possible obstruction of justice charges against the man who reported
the existence of red residue on fabric of seats recovered from the jumbo
jet ...... Sanders' attorney, Jeff Schlanger of New York, said authorities
had not consulted with him or his client about phone records before either
subpoena. Sanders on Wednesday called the subpoenas "harassment."
"I had and continue to have a constitutional right
to investigate federal wrongdoing," Sanders said. Sanders, the
author of the book "The Downing of TWA Flight 800," believes that a Navy
missile struck the Paris-bound jetliner July 17, 1996. ... Sanders says evidence
given to him by crash investigators showed that a missile with an inert warhead
pierced the right side of the Boeing 747 and passed out the left side, breaching
the center fuel tank in the process. The evidence included pieces of seat
material embedded with a reddish residue that contained elements consistent
with solid rocket fuel, according to independent non-government tests and
analysts. .... Shortly after Sanders' information was published in The
Press-Enterprise on March 10, the FBI disclosed it was investigating him
for suspected obstruction of justice and tampering with evidence from an
aircraft accident..... Sanders has co-authored two non-fiction books about
missing American prisoners of war from 20th-century conflicts: "Soldiers
of Misfortune" in 1992 and "The Men We Left Behind" in 1993. He has appeared
before Congress as an expert witness about POW issues.
October 9, 1997 New York Times
Airlines around the world will begin inspecting their planes' fuel tanks
for conditions that could cause an explosion like the one that destroyed
TWA Flight 800, the airlines and plane manufacturers announced Wednesday.
The airlines, which plan to pool the data from the inspections, are still
emphatically resisting the argument by the National Transportation Safety
Board that the way to prevent future explosions may be to insulate the tanks
to keep them cool, or to inject inert gases into the tanks. ........ The
airlines are adamant that the equipment currently in use is safe .....The
airlines made their announcement on the second day of a three-day conference
here on the safety of transportation fuels. The conference is jointly sponsored
by the Federal Aviation Administration, which has also been unenthusiastic
about the National Transportation Safety Board's ideas...... Hall said
that the board's inability to identify the probable cause "masked a very
important fact about the(TWA 800) investigation, and that is that we know
what happened to the aircraft" -- the center fuel tank exploded.... But airline
representatives Wednesday reiterated their contention that until the safety
board knows the source of the spark that caused the explosion, or mechanics
spot something on a plane that they can identify as a flaw, it is too soon
to make any hardware or procedural changes. ..... Airlines and the FAA often
differ sharply with the safety board, but this dispute stands in striking
contrast to another now taking shape, over the crash of a
USAir 737 near Pittsburgh in 1994. In that case,
the FAA, Boeing and the airlines appear to agree on safety steps, modifying
the rudder assembly, but Boeing still disputes that the rudder was the cause
of the crash. In the TWA 800 case, the airlines and manufacturers are disputing
the solution even though they generally agree with the safety board that
the center fuel tank exploded.
October 10, 1997 4 Jumaada al-awal 1415 A.H. 9
Tishri 5758 (Yom Kippur)
Reported by Associated Press October 11, 1997
Falling like a fireball from the sky, an Argentine airliner crashed
and exploded in Uruguay, killing all 75 people aboard, ..... The pilot had
been trying to dodge a turbulent storm. The Austral airlines DC-9 all but
disintegrated when it slammed into farmland at 11 p.m. Friday near Nuevo
Berlin, in eastern Uruguay. It was the deadliest crash ever involving an
Argentine airliner. ..... ''The plane hit the ground with a heavy impact
and is scattered over a very wide area.'' .....Seventy passengers and five
crew members were flying from the northern Argentine city of Posadas to Buenos
Aires, said Santiago Garcia, commercial manager of Austral. Officials said
most of the victims were Argentine but there were a few Uruguayans and one
Swiss. Three infants were among the dead. .... Lt. Col. Walter Garcia, an
Uruguayan civil aviation official, told The Associated Press that the storm
''explains only part'' of the accident,
but did not elaborate. He said the flight data recorders must be found to
help determine the exact cause. The crew had last made contact with the Buenos
Aires airport about 40 minutes before the crash and reported changing course
to avoid heavy rain and hail, air force spokesman Jorge Carnevalini said.
... Witnesses said the plane was already in flames
when it hit the ground and exploded. Roberto Lemos, who
was driving to the nearby town of Fray Bentos, said he saw what he thought
was a flash of lightning. ''Afterward, I realized it had been a plane.''
Ingrid Bidegain de Bastos, who lives on a nearby farm, described seeing a
''red ball that fell and exploded on hitting the ground.''
October 20, 1997 The Press-Enterprise, Riverside, CA
A meteorologist. A commercial fisherman. A commuter airline pilot. Three
eyewitnesses to the fiery midair breakup of TWA 800 share one clear recollection
-- an ascending object struck the jumbo jet. Yet when federal
investigators reinterviewed 244 of the more than 400 eyewitnesses to the
crash, no agency -- not the FBI or the CIA, not the Federal Aviation
Administration or the National Transportation Safety Board -- conducted a
follow-up interview with any of the three, whose accounts have not been widely
published. Their initial recollections, given within hours of the disaster
July17, 1996, remain part of the classified record of the second most deadly
aviation crash in U.S. history. "I find it all very
intriguing," said Paul Beaver, an editor and missile specialist
with Jane's, a British publishing and research group. .....
"From Jane's perspective, we would like to say this
leaves the whole question of what happened to TWA 800 in the
balance," Beaver said in an interview. The accounts are
"an indication that it may be something more than
a catastrophic (mechanical) event."
The meteorologist and the airline pilot were among the first people to report the incident to authorities. All three said they talked to FBI agents within 24 hours of the incident. FBI spokesman Joe Valiquette declined to discuss any eyewitness accounts. He said they were part of a continuing investigation. ...... The three witnesses each described colored objects heading upward until they disappeared with the emergence of a large fireball that later was identified as Flight 800. Two, who witnessed events from boats, described speedy flare-like objects while the third, an airline pilot, told of a strange yellow light that he thought might pass near his jetliner. One saw a bright flash before the plane exploded and another saw the plane split into three pieces. Beaver said accounts of a flare-like object, even on a zigzag course, ascending toward the plane are consistent with some types of missiles that use infrared guidance systems. He said a missile's burning solid fuel can emit a reddish glow, with the intensity and duration depending on the specific type of projectile and its purpose. Beaver has been naval editor and aerospace and defense editor for Jane's. He is a pilot, British army reserve officer, has fired air-to-ground missiles and has observed missile tests. A witness' account of how long he saw a reddish streak could be affected by the point in flight he picked up the object, Beaver said. A bright white flash, reported by some witnesses, could be solid fuel exploding, he said. Some military drones, including a Banshee or Firebee, also emit red glows from the exhaust, with visibility depending on the background, Beaver said.
The accident's initiating event probably occurred at 8:31.13 p.m. EDT, NTSB officials say. Near sunset, the background and visibility depended upon whether witnesses faced east or west and their altitude. The FBI investigated orange-colored metal in May that was found among the Flight 800 debris recovered from the Atlantic Ocean off New York's Long Island. Officials said the metal was compared with a Firebee drone -- a stubby, bright orange, jet fighter-shaped unmanned vehicle -- but results of the study have not been made public. ...... Another witness, ex-Air National Guard helicopter pilot Maj. Fred Meyer, was on a routine training flight that evening and said he saw a reddish streak and two aerial explosions -- the first reddish orange and the second bright white -- before Flight 800 erupted into a fireball. He said that, based on his military experience, he believes the airliner was struck by some type of military ordnance but could not be positive it was a missile. His co-pilot, Capt. Chris Baur, said within hours of the incident that he thought a missile brought the plane down. Meyer said he has not been re-interviewed by the FBI since shortly after the crash and Baur is under government orders not to discuss the incident.
Beaver said the eyewitness accounts did not point to a specific missile or provide conclusive proof Flight 800 was brought down by a missile. However, based on the eyewitness accounts, "I wouldn't want to put it (missile) out of the question," Beaver said. "It keeps the debate open, which is just as important". FBI and CIA officials say they have reinterviewed and analyzed reports of 244 witnesses and determined that what the people saw happened after the initiating event and was "the burning (Boeing) 747 in various stages of crippled flight, not a missile." Some investigation analysts say witnesses mistook pressurized sprays of flaming fuel going downward for something that looked like a missile or emergency flare headed upward. All of the witnesses interviewed by The Press-Enterprise said they were never reinterviewed by the FBI or CIA and what they saw started before the midair explosion, not after. Neither the FBI nor the CIA would discuss their guidelines for deciding whom to reinterview or how they categorized witnesses' reliability. (Click for Eyewitness Reports and Witness Reliability Calculations)
October 23, 1997 New York Times
As smoke billowed from the towers of the World Trade Center on Feb. 26, 1993,
after a huge blast had torn through the center's garage, a man watched intently
from the Jersey City waterfront. The man, Ramzi Ahmed Yousef, may
have had mixed feelings as he gazed across the Hudson River, a Secret Service
agent suggested in testimony in U.S. District Court on Wednesday. While the
blast killed six people and injured more than 1,000, Yousef had hoped it
would topple one of the Trade Center towers and kill tens of thousands, the
agent testified. ..... Secret Service agent, Brian G. Parr, described what
he said were Yousef's admissions about his direct role in the bomb plot,
his motives and goals, and where he had thought he had failed.
"He said it was in retaliation for U.S. aid to Israel,"
Parr testified at one point. "I asked,
why not select Israeli targets? He said Israeli targets were too difficult
to attack. He said if you cannot attack your enemy, you should attack the
friend of your enemy." ... "He related to us that during World war II the
Americans had dropped the atomic bombs on the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki,
killing 250,000 civilians, and he said that the Americans would realize if
they suffered those types of casualties that they were at war,"
Parr said. ...... Parr testified that Yousef agreed to talk to him and another
agent, Charles Stern of the FBI, on the flight on the condition that they
not take notes or record the conversation. During breaks in the interview,
the two agents would go to another part of the plane and reconstruct the
conversation, writing down their notes, Parr testified. ...... Yousef
said he had received financing for the bombing from family members and friends,
though he would not elaborate. Had he more money, he said, he would have
made "a more efficient bomb." As for the timing of the attack, Parr testified,
it was chosen for practical rather than political reasons.
"They actually were out of money, and they didn't
have enough to pay next month's rent," Parr recounted.
"That's how they chose that date." In
making his preparations for the bombing, Yousef said that "on four or five
occasions he had gone out to rural areas outside of New York, and had done
test explosions," the agent said. Although Yousef did not identify the locations,
he asked the agents whether residents in those areas may have heard the noises
or known of the test explosions, Parr testified. ..... Asked about cyanide
found by investigators in a self-storage unit, Yousef said that he had originally
considered carrying out "a poison gas attack" on the trade center but decided
that it would be "too expensive to implement." .... After the explosion,
Yousef said he advised others involved in the plot to leave the country,
Parr said Wednesday. The agent also asked Yousef about the decision by one
of the plotters, Mohammed Salameh, to return to a Ryder rental agency in
Jersey City and ask for a refund of the deposit on the van used in the bombing.
"I asked him why Mr. Salameh ever went back to retrieve
that $400 deposit," Parr testified, "and he looked at me with a grin and
in one word said: 'Stupid.'
"
October 23, 1997 New York Times
Delivering his most militant and impassioned speech since his return to Gaza
three weeks ago, Sheik Ahmed Yassin, the guiding symbol of the militant
Islamic movement Hamas, vowed Wednesday not to abandon holy war against Israel.
"A nation that does not wage jihad cannot exist,"
Yassin proclaimed to 3,000 exultant students at Islamic University
in Gaza City, using the Islamic term for a holy struggle.
"God is with us and Satan with them. We will fight
and fight until we regain our rights and our homeland, God willing."
... At the time of his release, the 61-year-old religious leader
affirmed the possibility of a truce with Israel, though the terms he set
were the stock conditions of past Hamas cease-fire offers, including full
Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank and Gaza Strip and the removal of all
Jewish settlements. Israel has never taken these offers seriously. In subsequent
interviews and addresses, Yassin has increasingly urged a continued holy
war. .... "I want to proclaim loudly to the world
that we are not fighting Jews because they are Jews," .... "We are fighting
them because they assaulted us, they killed us, they took our land, our homes,
our children, our women, they scattered us, we became scattered everywhere,
a people without a homeland. We want our rights. We don't want more. We love
peace, but they hate the peace, because people who take away the rights of
others don't believe in peace. Why should we not fight? We have our right
to defend ourselves."
October 25, 1997 New York Times
A power failure that knocked out traffic lights, caused home computers to
crash and disrupted the morning for much of San Francisco on Thursday
(October 23, 1997 (n)) appears to have
been an act of sabotage, the authorities said Friday. .... the power failure
was described by utility officials as the worst act of sabotage of a power
system in at least a decade. The blackout, starting around 6:15 a.m. and
covering a large part of the business district and many residential
neighborhoods, was traced to a single substation owned by Pacific Gas &
Electric, San Francisco's main power provider. At the substation, officials
found that 39 power-control switches had been manually turned in a way that
halted the flow of electricity. Whoever caused the blackout would have needed
a key to enter the substation and knowledge of how to shut down the system,
the authorities said. ...... A counterterrorism task force was involved in
the investigation, but officials played down suggestions that the blackout
was an act of domestic terrorism. "We are exploring
all possibilities," said Bob Griego, an FBI spokesman in the city.
"But we have been told there was no mechanical failure, so at this point
we're investigating it as an intentional act." ....
"It's fair to say it required some expertise to accomplish what was done,"
said Leonard Anderson, a spokesman for the utility.
"What happened was extremely unusual, a rare
occurrence." .... The blackout has raised questions about the vulnerability
of the 16 substations around San Francisco, all of which are locked but
unguarded. ..... this was a very deliberate attempt to knock out power."
The power failure came just as the city was stirring to life in
the predawn darkness. Coffeepots went off. Electric garage doors remained
shut. Lights went off. Power serving 126,000 customers was gone until about
9:45 a.m. in part of downtown and the neighborhoods of North Beach, the Marina,
Pacific Heights, the Sunset District and the Richmond District. ....
"Except for the earthquake of 1989, I can't recall
an outage of similar magnitude," said Tony Novello, enforcement
director at the Department of Parking and Traffic. Officials at the electric
utility said they could not recall any time in recent memory when such an
event left so many people without power. "Sabotage
is rather unique," said Eugene Gorzelnik, a spokesman for the
North American Electric Reliability Council, a utility organization based
in Princeton, N.J. "The few instances, you can probably
count them on a couple of fingers."
October 26, 1997 Agence France-Press New York
Times
Iran today derided attempts in Washington to undercut its arms deals with
other countries. The Foreign Minister ... castigated the US Congress for
its efforts to punish nations found to be helping Iran to build missiles.
.... Iranian military officials said... that the country had become the strongest
"missile power" in the region and announced the manufacture of missiles,
planes and missile-launching boats. Hashemi Rafsanjani, Iran's former
President, said .. that Iran possessed long-rang anti-aircraft missiles
able to reach into the Persian Gulf ....
November 11, 1997 The New York Times
A Pakistani immigrant was convicted of murder Monday night for killing two
CIA employees stuck in morning rush-hour traffic outside the intelligence
agency's Virginia headquarters nearly five years ago.... Mir Amal Kansi,
33, faces a possible death sentence. .... Kansi was captured in June after
a four-and-a-half-year search that reached from Washington's suburbs to the
mountains of Afghanistan and to the deserts of Pakistan. He was the lone
suspect in the killings from the moment he fled the United States after the
shootings, which injured three other people on Jan. 25, 1993, outside the
Central Intelligence Agency's headquarters in Langley, Va. The search for
Kansi took place "in the face of often overwhelming difficulties," said William
Esposito, deputy director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. A son of
a relatively wealthy family from Quetta, a rugged city bordering Afghanistan,
he had eluded an international manhunt that took FBI agents into the lawless
Afghan borderlands. His motive, as best it could
be determined, was anger at American foreign policy in the Middle East. He
was especially furious over the Persian Gulf war and the treatment of
Palestinians by Israel, said Special Agent Bradley Garrett of
the FBI, who helped arrest Kansi at a cheap hotel in Pakistan and testified
against him last week. Kansi, whose surname is also spelled Kasi, gave a
detailed confession to the FBI team as they flew to the United States from
Pakistan, Garrett testified. Kansi said he believed
that the United States and the CIA had too much power over Islamic nations
like Pakistan. His hometown was a base for a $3-billion CIA
paramilitary operation that was designed to arm the Afghan guerrillas who
were fighting off Soviet occupiers during the 1980s. Garrett said Kansi told
him he chose the CIA headquarters as a target to
"convey a message to the United States."
..... He was tried under Virginia law, not federal terrorist statutes.
Legally speaking, because Kansi appeared to have acted alone, and not as
part of a terrorist group, it was a simple case of murder.
November 12, 1997 Associated Press
Four American businessmen and a Pakistani are dead today after gunmen ran
their car off a road in Karachi and riddled it with bullets. Police say they've
launched a manhunt for the attackers. The Americans were auditors for the
Houston-based oil company, Union Texas Petroleum. The company says it is
evacuating all of its 30 personnel in the country immediately. The shooting
comes two days after a Virginia jury convicted a Pakistani man of killing
two CIA employees. The State Department has warned Americans in Pakistan
and elsewhere to be wary of possible retaliatory attacks.
November 12, 1997 The Associated Press
The FBI has told families of victims of TWA Flight 800 that it
"has found absolutely no evidence" of
a crime and is suspending its probe into the disaster.....Kallstrom told
families, "I must report to you ... that our
investigation has found absolutely no evidence to cause us to believe that
the TWA Flight 800 tragedy was the result of a criminal act" ....
The FBI plans a news conference next week to issue a comprehensive report
on the criminal probe's findings, a law-enforcement source said. .... Kallstrom's
letter....said the FBI's sole mission was to determine
"with a high degree of certainty" if
there was any evidence of a criminal act, and if so,
"to bring those responsible to justice."
Breistroff, who lost his son Michel in the crash, said he and other family
members overseas now plan a campaign to have all 747s grounded.
"This plane is obviously a dangerous plane,"
he said. "It took investigators all these
months and all these millions of dollars to tell us that. Therefore the plane
should be forbidden to fly."
November 13, 1997 New York Times
It was almost five years ago, but the images are still etched in memory:
the explosion rumbling over the city like summer thunder, a blast furnace
of fire under the World Trade Center, smoke and panic rising through the
falling snow, jangling alarms, death and America awaking to the horrors of
terrorism. ... But Wednesday, in a courtroom a few blocks away, the conviction
of Ramzi Ahmed Yousef as the leader of the plot, and of Eyad Ismoil
as the accomplice who drove the enormous car bomb into the Trade Center's
underground garage and helped Yousef detonate it, brought the tangled case
to a kind of close. Secrets still seem to lurk in its dark corners, and some
may be important. Investigators say they may never learn whether the plotters
had the backing of a government or Middle East terrorist group or acted
independently, raising cash from family members and friends. And much
about Yousef, from his background to his name, remains a mystery.
"We have more answers than questions,"
Mary Jo White, the U.S. attorney in Manhattan, said at a news
conference after the verdict last night. "But there
are still questions." .... The agent .. quoted Yousef as saying
he had done it .... to avenge the Palestinian people
for what he called decades of Israeli persecution, and to retaliate against
America for supporting Israel. This and other testimony, .. was
enough to convince the jury. But .... prosecutors aiming at criminal convictions
had no need to address the larger mysteries surrounding the defendant. Thus,
questions were unanswered: Did a country or terrorist group sponsor Yousef,
as some investigators suspect? Or did he act independently, as others
believe, recruiting and training amateurs in New York, Manila and elsewhere
for diabolical plots to topple the Trade Center, kill the pope and blow up
12 U.S. airliners? And, not least, who is Ramzi Ahmed Yousef? Much about
him -- his nationality, associations, even his name -- remains unclear. In
his six months in the United States before the bombing, officials say, he
repeatedly changed disguises and identities, and over the years used 11 aliases
and many passports and other false identity papers. While much about his
origins are murky, investigators say he was born on April 27, 1968, to a
Pakistani mother and a Palestinian father and grew up in a working-class
Kuwait City suburb. Like many Palestinians in Kuwait, he and his family were
second-class citizens, exiles in a diaspora who
despised Israel for taking their land, and blamed the United States for
supporting Israel. Yousef, who speaks Urdu, the main Pakistani
language, as well as Arabic and English, studied engineering at Swansea
University in Wales from 1986 to 1989. Intelligence reports say he went to
Afghanistan after the mujahedeen rebels, backed by the CIA, drove Soviet
troops out in 1989, and was trained in guerrilla fighting. Some reports say
he learned bomb-making in Peshawar, a
Pakistani town near the Afghan border that was a center of guerrilla activity
in the 1980s. The town is near the Khyber Pass frontier, a lawless land that
has long been a training ground and sanctuary for terrorists. In 1991, Yousef
moved to the Philippines and joined the Muslim extremist group known as Abu
Sayyaf. A former deputy commander of the movement recalled Yousef as a bitterly
anti-American Palestinian militant who had resolved to wage an ambitious
campaign of terrorism around the world. Yousef arrived in New York on a flight
from Pakistan on Sept. 1, 1992. Using a false Iraqi
passport, he asked for political asylum, and was released pending
a hearing. Ahmad M. Ajaj, a Palestinian, accompanied Yousef on the flight.
Yousef began seeking recruits through the Jersey City mosque of Sheik Omar
Abdel-Rahman, the blind Egyptian cleric whose most ardent Muslim followers
were militant opponents of the United States. In 1995 the sheik and 10 followers
were convicted of conspiring to blow up the United Nations headquarters and
other New York buildings, bridges and tunnels in a campaign of urban terrorism.
Through the mosque, investigators say, Yousef recruited Mohammed Salameh,
Nidal Ayyad and Mahmoud Abouhalima. They helped him buy and mix explosive
chemicals in cheap apartments and a rented storage space in Jersey City.
Abdul Rahman Yasin, an Iraqi, also was recruited, officials say. ..... Yousef
set the fuse and fled before the blast. Within hours, Yousef flew to Karachi,
Pakistan, and Ismoil to Amman, Jordan, leaving the others behind. Yasin also
fled, and remains the only fugitive. Yousef ... renewed his campaign of terror,
traveling to Pakistan, Thailand, the Philippines and eventually back to
Islamabad, where Pakistani and U.S. agents, acting on a tip, seized him on
Feb. 7, 1995. It was on the flight back to New York that he talked to Brian
G. Parr of the Secret Service and Charles Stern of the FBI.
His confession was said to have included plans for
a kamikaze attack on the CIA headquarters in Langley, Va., and an attempt
to assassinate President Clinton with phosgene gas. When Yousef
fled the Philippines, he left a computer full of plots, one to kill Pope
John Paul II in Manila in days, another for a horror to surpass that at the
Trade Center: a coordinated bombing of 12 American jetliners in 48 hours.
(For the latter, he was convicted in New York last year and faces mandatory
life in prison.) In his trials and statements, there has been no evidence
that Yousef was working for a foreign power or terrorist group. But other
investigators say his ability to travel the world
as a fugitive with relative ease make it unlikely that he acted on his own.
Likely sponsors include Syria, Iran, Libya or a terrorist
organization, they theorize. Thus Yousef, to the end, has remained
an enigma. By refusing to testify in his own defense at either of his trials,
he has avoided exposing himself to prosecutors'
questions about possible sponsors and financing by enemies of the United
States, or even to more searching questions about who he is.
November 19, 1997 New York Times
(T)he FBI provided an unusual public explanation Tuesday of how it had become
convinced that the crash was not the result of sabotage. The centerpiece
of the presentation was a computer- generated videotaped reconstruction of
the crash, produced by the CIA, that sought to explain the reports of 244
witnesses who said they saw ascending lights before the plane plunged into
the Atlantic Ocean. ....... James K. Kallstrom, the head of the New York
office of the FBI, said the FBI's decision to suspend its investigation
"is based solely on the overwhelming absence of
evidence indicating a crime, and the lack of any leads that could bear on
the issue. In fact, we ran out of things to do.". ..... In fact,
Kallstrom said, most people who believed they saw
a missile were actually seeing different stages of the fiery breakup of the
aircraft. And after the plane first exploded, blowing off the cockpit and
front section of the fuselage, the flaming rear section zoomed upward several
thousand feet, giving some witnesses the impression that a missile was rising
in the sky ...... Representatives of TWA and the plane's manufacturer,
Boeing Corp., said Tuesday there was no indication of any flaws, either in
Flight 800 or in 747s in general. James Brown, a spokesman for TWA, added
that investigators had found no sign of a human error leading to the explosion
and crash. "At this point we're satisfied with all
our procedures," he said. "The FBI even
noted that our security and baggage handling procedures on Flight 800 were
flawless." Despite Kallstrom's presentation,
Pierre Salinger, the journalist who last
year publicly embraced the theory that a U.S. military missile had struck
the plane, said he would await the results of the safety board's investigation.
"I have talked to Kallstrom," he said,
"I said I wasn't going to be talking about it any
more. But I still believe what I said
was true." ..... Kallstrom said, for example, that forensic experts
had analyzed more than 1,400 holes in the many layers
of metal in the recovered pieces of the plane, determining their
relationship with each other in hopes finding a telltale path through which
a missile or other object might have moved.
November 18, 1997 Boeing Statement on FBI's TWA 800
Investigation
The FBI's assessment that it has not found any criminal evidence in the
investigation of the loss of TWA Flight 800 does not change the role of The
Boeing Company role in the continuing effort to determine the cause of this
tragedy. The role of The Boeing Company in the investigation remains the
same as it has been since the early hours following the crash: We continue
to assist the National Transportation Safety Board in their effort to determine
what happened and why. We will keep providing whatever information and resources
we can to help in that effort, including participating in the upcoming NTSB
public hearing. Boeing provided information about the design, operation and
performance of the 747 to the FBI throughout their criminal investigation.
However, Boeing was not involved in the production
of the video shown today, nor have we had the opportunity to obtain a copy
or fully understand the data used to create it. While we provided basic
aerodynamic information to assist in the CIA's analysis of the airplane's
performance, we are not aware of the data that was used to develop the
video. The video's explanation of the
eyewitness observations can be best assessed by the eyewitnesses
themselves. Since the beginning of the investigation, Boeing has
never subscribed to any one theory. Our role continues to be to assist in
determining how and why this tragedy occurred. We remain committed to that
goal.
November 19, 1997 New York Post
Witnesses to the fiery TWA crash don't accept the FBI's explanation of the
mysterious streaks they saw in the sky that fateful night. .... the FBI concluded
that the witnesses were confused because they saw flaming pieces of wreckage
break off before they heard the explosion - because light travels faster
than sound. Those who spoke to The Post yesterday were highly skeptical.
"I'm not satisfied at all," said East
End fisherman Ronald [Roland] Penney,
who insists he saw a "streak of light" racing into the sky just before the
plane exploded. "I don't think they're being honest
with the people. They're telling us we saw something else than what we say.
I think it was a missile and I don't believe them."
"I know what I saw," agreed
Barbara Pacholk, a 50-year old housewife
from Quogue. "I saw
several
fires go across the sky.
One
hit the plane at the tail and the
second
hit at the front, just before the wings. The fire came from both ends and
met in the middle and exploded. Then the nose dropped, hung there for a minute.
I understand that when a plane bursts into flames the flames fall, but this
was a fire going up towards the plane,.....I wouldn't accuse anyone of
wrongdoing, but I'm definitely still wondering what happened."
November 19, 1997 The Press-Enterprise, Riverside, CA
One of the crash's key eyewitnesses ... believes Tuesday's FBI presentation
was purposely tainted. "I saw the news
conference," said Meyer, who
was piloting an Air National Guard rescue helicopter the night of the crash
when he saw TWA 800 explode. "I saw the (CIA video)
scenario. It just isn't what happened. They've changed the sequence of events."
Meyer, a combat veteran who had missiles fired at his helicopter
in Vietnam, said he saw a streak approach the jetliner in a slight downward
arc, two small but sharp explosions, and then the huge fireball that fell
to the ocean.
November 21, 1997 New York Times
The militant Islamic Group, which has claimed responsibility for the strike
that killed 58 foreign tourists in Luxor, issued a statement Thursday taunting
the Egyptian government, which it has said was the real target of the attack.
The organization, the largest Islamic militant group in Egypt, said it might
be willing to halt its military operations "for a while." But the group said
it would do so only if the government took steps that Egypt has repeatedly
rejected, including halting its security crackdown against the militants
and severing relations with Israel. ....... As part of the price for a suspension
of its attacks, the group demanded in Thursday's statement the release of
thousands of prisoners, including its spiritual leader,
Sheik Omar Abdel Rahman, who remains
in an American jail after his conviction in connection with the plot to bomb
the World Trade Center and other prominent targets.
November 24, 1997 The New York Observer
Partial text of article entitled "File This Case Under
‘X’: Flight 800 Goes Unsolved" by Philip Weiss
"Jim Naples
doesn’t want to talk to me at first, and I can’t blame him. But standing
outside on the deck of his seaside home, he thinks it over, then summons
me across his yard. ..... “We know what we saw.
We weren’t drunk,” said the burly contractor.
“I looked up and my immediate response was, I never
saw an alert flare like that. It was projecting upward with a stream of smoke
behind.” It was twilight on July 17, 1996, and Jim Naples was
out on his boat with his wife and two daughters. Hundreds of other coastal
people were out on the water that night, too, and scores of them saw what
Jim Naples saw in the southern sky: a white jet trail streaking up from near
the horizon and arcing through the sky for many seconds, and later a fireball
as big as the sundiesel fuel exploding on Trans World Airlines Flight
800. Now the F.B.I. has reached its conclusion in the matter.
Its message to the eyewitnesses: Shut up, you
didn’t see anything. I first heard tape recordings of two unrelated
witnesses who offered remarkably similar views of something streaking up
and then angling horizontally that night to those made by a retired commander
of the United States Navy,
William
Donaldson, and played at the
Accuracy in Media
conference in Washington last month. Then I banged around
Center Moriches for a day or so and soon met six people who said they were
eyewitnesses, whose accounts were similar to the ones Commander Donaldson
had recorded. “What we saw was a vapor trail, it
looked like fireworks going up,” said
Paul Runyan.
“They say, Was it like a missile? I don’t know,
I’ve never seen a missile.”
“My brother noticed it first, he said it was
fireworks,” said Michelle
Dorney, a teenager who was in her family’s big house on a hill
overlooking the water in East Moriches. “I looked
out the window, and it was a straight line going up from over the condos.
It left a trail.” “It was very
white, we thought it was a flare,” said a
45-year-old Center Moriches woman who was out on the bridge of
her boat in the bay just north of Fire Island.
“It came up over the dunes from the east toward
the west, it curved up and started to fall. It never flared up. What struck
me was the whiteness of the trail; they’ve got to explain that to me before
I’m happy. A second later, we saw the first fireballlike a waterfall
of flame in the sky, six inches across.”
“It was like an alert flare, someone’s in
trouble,” Randy Penney told
me, after pressure-washing barnacles off the hull of a boat at Senix Marina.
“It was bright white and seemed to be drifting down.
Then later you saw the diesel fuel burning.” ....... The contempt
that the Government shows for common people is best demonstrated by the
C.I.A.’s response to The Press-Enterprise when it asked about the eyewitnesses.
“C.I.A. analysts have determined that the eyewitness sightings thought
to be that of a missile actually took place after the first of several explosions
on the aircraft,” C.I.A. spokeswoman Carolyn
Osborn said in September. “Our technical analysis concludes
that what these eyewitnesses saw was in fact the burning [Boeing] 747 in
various stages of crippled flight, not a missile.” Is it really possible
that people saw the Boeing, which was at 13,000 feet, flying up from “over
the dunes,” or coming up “over the condos”? That dozens of people who say
they saw a white-hot flare many seconds before a diesel explosion were wrong,
that the flare was after? And who is the C.I.A.
to say the witnesses claimed to see a missile when none of the ones I talked
to made that explicit claim? The Government’s treatment of the
eyewitnesses has already fostered deep cynicism in the Center Moriches area.
“It would be one thing if just three or four or
five people saw it,” said Anita Langdon
at her boat-motor shop at the Senix Marina.
“But 50 or 60 people saw it in Center Moriches,
well-respected citizens, and they know what they saw.” ..... The
investigators’ arrogance toward the eyewitnesses angered Representative James
Traficant Jr., Democrat of Ohio, who earlier this fall, at the behest of
the chairman of the House Aviation Subcommittee, began investigating the
possibility that the Government is shortchanging the citizens’ views.
“She [Ms. Osborn] said they were mistaken in what
they saw. That’s not very professional, and it’s not the way to dispute
eyewitness statements,” said Paul
Marcone, press secretary to the Congressman.
“Those witness statements should be part of the
public record. And they [the F.B.I.] have to come up with a credible scenario
of why the eyewitnesses saw what they saw.” Representative
Traficant’s hope that the witnesses will be happily reconciled with the official
version, let alone treated honestly and openly, is, I think, naïve.
If the government was investigating reports that the emperor was naked, it
would call in designers, clothing historians and fashion editors, all well
paid, all authoritative, all above reproach, to produce lengthy, detailed
reports saying that ordinary people hadn’t seen what they’d seen. The media
would duly report it and piss on the common man’s view.
“I don’t think our accounts will be reflected in
the final version,” said Jim
Naples. “I have a hard time believing
that the F.B.I. believes its conclusions … I don’t believe that the truth
is ever going to come out.” ........ Two magazine editors recently
explained the current media Zeitgeistto me over lunch: “Everything you see
on the front page is good news.” It’s the Emperor’s New Clothes as national
vision. .... The people I buttonholed in Center Moriches all seemed to wish
they could be rubberneckers, taking stuff in stridenot witnesses to
the crash with the witnesses’ traditional responsibility. They didn’t want
to talk about what they’d seen, or were scared that they’d seen what they’d
seen. Some wished they’d never seen it. “In my opinion,
we’re never going to find out what happened,” said the
45-year-old woman on the bridge.
“And I don’t know that I
care.”"
November 23, 1997 New York Times
In the three years since the bombing of a Jewish community center here killed
87 people and wounded hundreds, the (Argentinian) government has made little
progress in identifying those responsible for the attack. The authorities
have said that it is highly unlikely they will ever catch the bombers, who
they believe are Muslim militants. But they have high hopes of capturing
what investigators call the "local connection" -- the Argentines who
investigators have said provided the attackers with the vehicle, explosives,
intelligence, immigration documents and other support. ...... investigators
said that the family of a former police commander who has been charged with
supplying the vehicle used in the attack received $2.5 million a week before
the bombing reduced the Argentina Israeli Mutual Association community center
to a heap of rubble. ......While the origin of the
money is unknown, investigators said they believe it was payment from terrorists
for .... help. Ribelli, two deputy commanders and an inspector
of the provincial police force were arrested last year and charged as accomplices
in the bombing. .... "It's a very important piece
of the puzzle that we've tried to assemble for three years." ..... Investigators
said they are now seeking to learn the origins of the $2.5 million.
.... Leaders of Argentine Jewish groups, who have complained that
the investigation is moving too slowly, said the recent congressional disclosures
confirm their suspicions that the provincial police were deeply involved
in the attack. "No one pays $2.5 million only for
the delivery of a van," said Ruben Beraja, chairman of the Argentine
Jewish Groups Federation. ..... The government has come under pressure from
Jewish groups to exhaust all possibilities in investigating the community
center blast and to prevent future terrorism. The attack followed a 1992
bombing of the Israeli Embassy here in which 29 people were killed. That
case has also not been resolved. Today, Argentine Jews live in a virtual
state of siege. Synagogues and Jewish schools are protected by police, barricades
and guard dogs.
November 27, 1997 The New York Times
The Federal Aviation Administration on Wednesday ordered an immediate change
in fuel pumps in Boeing 747s and also proposed a change in the wiring of
older 747s, saying that tests conducted after the crash of TWA Flight 800
pointed to both as potential causes of a mid-air explosion. Although
"there is no evidence from the accident airplane
that leads us to conclude that either one of these is the cause of the
accident," said Thomas E. McSweeny, director of the FAA's aircraft
certification service, the agency believed it was "prudent" to make the
changes...... exhaustive inquiries by the safety board and the FBI have yet
to pinpoint what actually caused the fumes to ignite ..... The FAA's action
comes less than two weeks before the NTSB is scheduled to begin hearings
in Baltimore into the cause of the crash. The FAA has now put itself on record
before those hearings as having taken some corrective action, if not the
one that the NTSB wanted. ...... In a conference call with reporters, McSweeny
said his agency decided to issue order the order regarding the fuel pumps
after tests showed that silicone seals used in parts of one of the fuel pumps
could dissolve on contact with jet fuel, which, in addition to powering the
plane, is used to cool and lubricate the pump motor. If the silicone
disintegrates, fuel could squirt into the wheel well behind the center tank,
where it could ignite, McSweeny. The pump in question is called a "scavenge
pump," which drains out the last few gallons from the center tank. The scavenge
pump from the TWA plane is part of the 4 percent of the airplane that searchers
have not recovered. In a statement Boeing also said that the silicone had
been added to some fuel pumps after their initial installation and that the
company had already issued a "service bulletin" to its customers "to inspect
and correct all scavenge pump connectors on affected 747s." ... The second
change sought by the FAA would be far more complicated and will be put out
for a 90-day public comment period. The agency wants airlines to replace
wiring in a place where wires enter the tank, known as the "fuel quantity
indication system." Investigators have long theorized that a spark was created
in this system, where fuel probes send signals back to the cockpit to tell
the crew how much fuel is left. .... in trying to assemble a plausible chain
of events to explain the destruction of Flight 800, investigators have also
found that 747s in airline service can have little pieces of metal in the
fuel tanks, and these can become lodged in the gaps of the fuel probes, where
they would help create a spark at lower voltages. .... In its statement,
Boeing said that it had conducted the testing to produce electrical surges.
The surges generated, however, were "far below what
would be required to present any hazard to the airplane," even
if contamination was present, the statement said.
"Earlier laboratory testing
using energy levels far in excess of
what is available on the airplane did
demonstrate the ability to create an arc in a fuel probe that had been purposely
contaminated with debris," the statement said. Boeing said it
would do additional tests before filing comments on the proposed rule.
November 27, 1997 The New York Times
Forty people accused of helping Algerian Islamic militants plant bombs that
killed eight people and wounded more than 170 in Paris in 1995 went on trial
this week. They are charged with conspiracy to support a terrorist campaign
to get the French government to drop support for the Algerian government.........
The defendants .... were arrested two years ago, after French commandos and
the police killed one of the suspected ringleaders of the bombings, Khalid
Kelkal, near Lyons and arrested hundreds of Algerians or people of Algerian
origin suspected of being part of an underground support network for the
Algerian Armed Islamic Group in France. ...... Three
of the defendants in this trial -- identified as Joseph Jaime, David Vallat
and Alain Celle -- are French citizens who converted to Islam and underwent
military training in Afghanistan, prosecutors said. .....
The French authorities say the operations here were
financed from Britain, where the Islamic group was able to publish a newsletter.
The French press often rails against Britain for its perceived laxity regarding
Islamic militants who are said to find
sanctuary in England. French newspapers
gave prominent display recently to similar charges by Egyptian President
Hosni Mubarak after the massacre of foreign tourists at Luxor last
week.
November 28, 1997 The New York Times
Iranian intelligence agents are mounting extensive
operations in Bosnia and have infiltrated the U.S. program to train the Bosnian
army, according to Western and Bosnian officials. The officials
said they had identified more than 200 Iranian agents who they believe have
quietly and methodically insinuated themselves into Bosnian Muslim political
and social circles. Their aim appears to be both gathering information and
thwarting Western interests in Bosnia....... "I
don't know why the Americans behave so naively," said Munir Alibabic,
the former chief of the Bosnian intelligence service's Sarajevo office. "They
should see what is happening to us," ... A senior official in Washington
insisted the Iranian intelligence network is not an immediate threat because
U.S. agents are watching it closely. ....But Western intelligence officers
in Bosnia are much more alarmed. They say many of the Iranian agents are
already working to turn Bosnia's Muslim political and religious leaders against
the West. The Iranian agents, they said, would be
helpful in planning terrorist attacks against NATO forces or targets in Europe.
.... Iran has been trying for several years to gain a foothold in Europe
through its relationship with the predominantly Muslim leadership of
Bosnia. It sold hundreds of millions of dollars in weapons to
Bosnia during the war against the Serbs, providing crucial aid at a time
when Western nations maintained an embargo on arms sales to any nation in
the former Yugoslavia. The Clinton administration learned of the smuggling
and decided on a secret policy of not interfering with the arms flow, which
helped the beleaguered Bosnians hold off the Serbs. ...Disclosure of the
secret U.S. policy after the war set off a political storm in Washington.
Some members of Congress charged that the administration had allowed Iran
to expand its influence in Bosnia.
December 1, 1997 Aviation Week and Space Technology
Recent tests on Boeing 747 scavenge pumps have all but ruled out the failure
of such a unit as a cause of the CFT explosion that ripped apart TWA Flight
800 - leaving NTSB investigators with rare wiring failures among the few
viable explanations for that blast. .... Separate testing and analyses have
eliminated a discharge of static electricity as a viable source of ignition.
As Safety Board officials ...convene a .. public hearing ... one official
familiar with the probe said, "All we have is a
tremendous absence of evidenceas to what caused the tank to explode".
December 5, 1997 Newsday.com
http://www.newsday.com/jet/year/cras1205.htm
Responding to pressure from the FBI on the eve of
the first public forum on the explosion of TWA Flight 800, the National
Transportation Safety Board has canceled the discussion of eyewitness accounts
and explosive residue at the five-day hearing into the cause of the crash.
(Click for text of
Kallstrom Letter to Hall) After an exchange of
letters Wednesday between Assistant FBI Director James Kallstrom and NTSB
Chairman Jim Hall, the safety board eliminated scheduled sessions on the
accounts and pulled a screening of the CIA video re-creation of the crash,
according to a copy of Hall's letter obtained yesterday. Reacting to Kallstrom's
concerns that the information would hinder any revived criminal probe, the
safety board also agreed to cut discussions of explosive residue found on
the plane's seats during the hearings ...... In effect, the concessions redress
all the objections set forth in Kallstrom's .... letter to Hall. ..... Despite
the fact that the FBI publicly concluded their criminal probe ......
Kallstrom warned Hall away from "the use
of any of the 244 eyewitness [accounts] ... or summaries prepared ... by
the NTSB." And he said that experts scheduled to analyze the
eyewitness testimony "could complicate our efforts
if the criminal investigation were to be reactivated. Until the NTSB has
definitively determined an accidental cause for the crash, I believe it is
prudent to withhold from public disclosure or discussion the identities of
witnesses and the raw investigative details of the criminal investigation,"
Kallstrom wrote in his letter. Since declaring that investigators
found no evidence of sabotage in the tragedy, Kallstrom has consistently
said the probe is not closed, opting to characterize it as inactive. In his
letter to Hall, he conceded that the possibility of rekindling the criminal
query is "remote." In a two-page response to the FBI objections, Hall told
Kallstrom that he didn't "see any fundamental
disagreement between our agencies." And while he said he would
comply with the "general objections" he said he was
"compelled to deny certain of your specific objections."
Those elements were not spelled out ....... Declining to comment
further, Hall issued a statement yesterday, saying that he would honor the
FBI's positions but that the NTSB would continue as planned to
"discuss its work done outside the criminal
investigative process -- including that work which overlaps in substance,
such as wreckage documentation and the examination of any and all potential
ignition sources." The revision of the hearings, which are meant
to present the NTSB's findings on the crash off Long Island, cancels testimony
by two experts, including Elizabeth Loftus, a University of Washington psychology
professor whose studies call into question the accuracy of eyewitness accounts,
according to sources. Loftus could not be reached yesterday. But the message
on her answering machine said she that she would be in Baltimore this weekend.
In his letter, Kallstrom said that "I believe that
the presentation of expert testimony that could cast doubt on the eyewitnesses'
veracity does not further the accident investigation."
December 5, 1997 CNN Web posted at: 9:15 p.m. EST (0215 GMT)
TWA's chief 747 pilot, a TWA flight attendant and the author of a book about
the TWA 800 crash have been charged with stealing pieces of the wreckage
from the hangar where investigators reconstructed the Boeing 747. .... arrest
warrants have been issued for James Sanders, author of "The Downing of TWA
Flight 800," his wife Liz Sanders, a TWA flight attendant, and TWA pilot
Terrell Stacey ... (Stacey) who as TWA's chief 747 pilot served as the airline's
number two representative in the crash investigation, allegedly took documents
and seat fabric from the wreckage at Liz Sanders' request. ....Stacey had
access to the wreckage because he was involved with three crash investigation
committees ..... "The FBI has spent millions creating
a videotape and holding a lengthy press conference to make sure their theory
got the public's attention," Schlanger (Sander's attorney) said.
"Why are they moving to arrest a person, a man who
holds that up to a little scrutiny?" According to the complaint
.....Stacey eventually provided James Sanders with information and copies
of reports on the crash investigation and pieces of fabric from some of the
plane's seats. ..... According to the complaint, those seats had a
reddish residue, unlike residue
on other seats on the plane. ....The FBI says its tests show that the
residue is an adhesive, but Sanders claims the FBI is involved in a cover-up.
He says, "I think they really do know with some certainty what
happened." ..... FBI deputy director James Kallstrom
sent a letter Wednesday to the National Transportation Safety Board asking
that it not discuss the residue during its public hearings scheduled to begin
Monday. He also asked the NTSB not to discuss other information
the FBI uncovered in its investigation, such as the identify of eyewitnesses
to the crash and testimony from experts regarding the limitations of the
eyewitness observations.
December 8, 1997 Aviation Week and Space Technology
Trans World Airlines officials aim to cast doubt this week on the NTSB's
investigation into the crash of its Flight 800, even reviving the question
of whether the 747 was downed by a missile. .... "We
are not convinced there was a spontaneous explosion in the center tank,"
said Mark Abels, TWA's vice president of corporate communications.
"We won't be until there is an ignition source
identified and there is proof it set off the explosion. All we see now is
circumstantial evidence." In meetings and correspondence with
the NTSB, TWA officials have indicated that they may challenge fundamental
elements of the Flight 800 investigation, including: How the NTSB tracked
where each piece of the 747's debris was found on the ocean floor .... and
how each was handled once ashore. .... The safety board's limited access
to the statements of witnesses who claimed to have seen a missile strike
Flight 800 ... The FBI gathered and controlled those statements as part of
its criminal investigation ...Although it has designated the investigation
as inactive, the FBI has yet to give the accident investigation team full
access to the witness reports.... The FBI's work
"doesn't mean there wasn't a missile,
it means the FBI has not found evidence of one," Abels said.
December 9, 1997 The New York Times
The National Transportation Safety Board, in its
first thorough presentation of the last moments of TWA Flight 800, displayed
its own video animation on Monday and painted a picture with significantly
different details from the one laid out by the CIA two weeks ago.
..... In the Safety Board's simulation -- without the music or professional
announcer of the CIA video -- the explosion in the center fuel tank took
less than a second to spew debris from the plane's belly, including part
of the keel beam, which provides much of the support for the fuselage. Then
the breakup of the plane slows or stops, but the nose begins to droop and
the sides compress, until the area in front of the wings breaks off, and
begins an almost leisurely flutter to the water, taking about 90 seconds.
The wings and everything behind them, however, continue
for more than two miles and climb from about 13,700 feet to perhaps 15,000
feet, before twisting north and south and plunging to the surface, with the
left wing breaking off shortly before impact, creating a fireball. The Central
Intelligence Agency's version, in contrast, portrayed the wings and fuselage
as climbing to 17,000 feet, trailing flaming fuel in a way that convinced
witnesses on the south shore of Long Island that they were seeing a missile.
And where the CIA has the major fragment of the plane veering to the north,
the Safety Board has it twist first north, toward the beach, and then
south. The first turn would have given observers the perspective
that the plane was continuing to climb, Board experts testified on Monday.
..... The investigators integrated information from eight radar sites around
the northeastern United States, radio transmissions from the Paris-bound
jet itself, "witness marks" showing where interior parts of the plane crashed
into each other, analyses of the trajectory that each part of the plane would
be expected to take as the Boeing 747 blew apart, locations of the wreckage
on the ocean floor, and analyses of thousands of fractures. They built a
case for explosion of the center fuel tank from causes internal to the plane,
although just what causes those were is not yet clear.
....... At the opening of hearings by the National Transportation Safety Board on TWA Flight 800, some 75 relatives of victims of the disaster sat silently Monday as engineers and scientists described in wrenching detail the destruction of the jumbo jet and its 230 passengers. Every detail except the critical one: what sparked the explosion in the center fuel tank that split the plane. ..... But for many others, the hearing offered a media spotlight for a variety of agendas they had developed in the wake of the disaster. Some are still pressing the theory that a missile downed the plane; some are urging new rules on airline safety or compensation for victims; still others continue to criticize the response of some officials to the disaster. .... Despite their deep concern about the outcome of the inquiry, the family members have no formal role in the hearings, which are limited to the technical aspects of the investigation. Frank Carven, a lawyer from Belair, Md., who lost his sister and nephew in the crash, said the frustration of some of the families built as the proceedings went on without any opportunity for critical questioning. .... Some relatives still doubted the federal government's conclusions that a missile was not the cause. When a man disrupted the opening moments of the hearing by raising a poster and yelling about a probable government cover-up, there was a quick smattering of applause from the tables reserved for families.
December 9, 1997 Associated Press
James Kallstrom, who led the FBI's investigation into the explosion of TWA
Flight 800 and helped bring down scores of organized-crime figures during
a 28-year career, said Tuesday he will retire from the agency at the end
of the month. "My time has come,'' the
FBI assistant director and chief of the agency's New York office said in
an interview with The Associated Press.
December 10, 1997 The New York Times
James Kallstrom, the FBI official in New York who tracked down terrorists,
mobsters and swindlers but who will probably be best remembered for his criminal
inquiry into the explosion that blew apart TWA Flight 800, said Tuesday that
he would retire from the bureau to take a job in the private sector. The
54-year-old ex-marine said he would probably have retired earlier had it
not been for the lengthy investigation into the Flight 800 disaster, which
killed all 230 people on board. Strongly suspecting that the cause was a
bomb or missile, Kallstrom led an exhaustive investigation that lasted 16
months and involved more than 1,000 agents. Ultimately, he said, the
investigation disproved his initial hunches. ....
"Imagine the notion of us looking for the obvious
things in an investigation and not finding them and sort of vacating the
scene," Kallstrom said at the time.
"We're the Federal Bureau of Total Investigation,"
he added, "not the Federal Bureau of the Obvious." .... Kallstrom
said that he would become a senior executive vice president of MBNA Corp.
of Wilmington, Del., which is the nation's second-largest credit card company
after Citicorp, with 25 million accounts and receivables of $46 billion.
... it was Kallstrom's blunt, no-nonsense approach to investigations that
inspired loyalty from agents and the public. While sometimes criticized as
being in the spotlight too often, he felt comfortable with reporters, and
could be relied upon for a colorful quote at a news conference.
When Ramzi Ahmed Yousef and two others were convicted
for plotting to blow up American commercial airliners in the Philippines,
Kallstrom described them as "cowardly scum."
December 10, 1997 The New York Times
In an effort to prevent explosions like the one that caused the crash of
TWA Flight 800, Boeing officials said Tuesday that the design of the company's
jetliners needed to be changed to guard against the build-up of flammable
fumes. Although the cause of the explosion on the Boeing 747 has still not
been determined, the company's statement was clear departure from a 40-year-old
principle of commercial aviation design. ..... Daniel Cheney, an FAA expert
in propulsion systems, said that "ever since aviation began," designers have
simply assumed that the fuel tanks held a flammable mixture and have instead
designed planes to prevent sources of ignition. "That assumption of flammability
has been successful but not successful enough," he said. Now, he said, the
government and airlines would look for ways to reduce the flammability of
vapor in the tanks. Stuart Matthews, president of the Flight Safety Foundation,
a non-profit group, said Boeing's statement was significant. "Everything
in the design is always, always, always, there will be no spark, no source
of ignition," he said. The investigators are acknowledging that they do not
know the cause of the crash, he said, "but they decided, belts and braces
are better than just belts." In fact, the hearings
have not thus far shed much light on the question of what set off the tank.
......... Despite the masses of data being presented at the hearing -- the
computer models, test flights, and other investigations -- some Safety Board
officials said they were concerned about some things that were being left
out, at the insistence of the FBI. .... Some investigators for the Safety
Board said the restrictions harmed the hearing process.
"This is supposed to be a complete factual
accounting," said one investigator, who
spoke only on condition that his name not be used.
"That's not right."
December 10, 1997 The New York Times
Iran opened a world Islamic conference Tuesday with a harsh denunciation
of the West, urging Muslim countries to resist what it called
"persistent and cunning enemies" led
by the United States and Israel. The country's supreme leader, Ayatollah
Ali Khamenei, told his guests that the main threat to security in the region
was not his own Islamic government, as many in the West assert, but
"the poisonous breath" of the United
States and its military presence in the Persian Gulf. .... But though Iran's
president later offered more conciliatory remarks, Ayatollah Khamenei's inaugural
seemed to signal Iran's intention as host of the three-day meeting to drive
home a message that Islam itself is under attack.
"Today, global arrogance gains hope and strength
through creating discord and disunity in this front," the ayatollah
said. "Is it not time to bolster and strengthen
this rank in our favor?" .... But the 45-minute address by the
conservative cleric put on center stage some of the hard-line views that
still carry great weight within powerful sectors of Iranian society eight
years after the death of Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, who inspired the revolution
that established Iran as the world's first Islamic republic. To underscore
the gravity with which it intended the ayatollah's address to be received,
the Iranian government circulated copies of the remarks in glossy pamphlets
that included translations from Persian into English, Russian, French and
Arabic. In his address, the ayatollah labeled as Iran's most dangerous critics
"the Zionists, the notorious global Zionist media,
and the agents of arrogance, in particular the Americans." And
he complained that "Western materialistic civilization
is directing everyone toward materialism while money, gluttony and carnal
desires are made the greatest aspirations." President Mohammed
Khatami, whose overwhelming victory in elections last spring has helped give
Iran a gentler face, later characterized relations between Islam and the
West in warmer terms. Khatami, who is also a cleric, said Islamic civil society
and its Western counterpart were "not necessarily in conflict and contradiction
in all their manifestations and consequences. "This is why we should never
be oblivious to judicious acquisition of the positive accomplishments of
the Western civil society," Khatami said. But Khamenei has emphasized since
the election that it is he, and not the president, who wields control over
foreign policy and most other matters of state. And because it was he, rather
than Khatami, who chose to inaugurate the conference Tuesday morning, the
most powerful impression left by the proceedings was his message of defiance.
The ayatollah chose not to single out Arab nations that have diplomatic or
commercial ties with Israel. But he condemned American-backed efforts to
broker a broader peace between Israel and the Palestinians as
"unjust, arrogant, contemptuous and, finally,
illogical," and he called them a "losing transaction" for the
Palestinians. On a matter closer to Iran's borders, he complained that
"the political designers of arrogance" -- a standard
euphemism for the United States and its Western allies -- "are breathing
their poisonous breath to make our neighbors in the Persian Gulf fearful
of Islamic Iran, which holds the banner of unity and brotherhood."
As Iran has done before, the ayatollah called on countries bordering
the Persian Gulf to band together for self-protection rather than rely on
outsiders like the United States.
December 10, 1997 The New York Times
The lawyer for a 52-year-old Virginia-based writer who was charged with illegal
possession of pieces of the wreckage of TWA Flight 800 tried Tuesday to portray
the matter as a free press issue. The writer, James Sanders, published a
book saying his investigation concluded that the plane was brought down by
a missile. Tuesday, he and his wife, Elizabeth Sanders, a 51-year-old flight
training supervisor for the airline, were in Federal District Court here
to answer charges of illegal possession of parts of the wreckage and of
withholding them from civil authorities. .... Sanders wrote that tests of
the fabric helped confirm that a missile had caused the jetliner to explode.
.... Schlanger said, "The action which the government has taken with respect
to the Sanderses, in choosing to invoke a relatively new statute which was
clearly intended to prevent looting of an aircraft and not situations like
those at hand, is unconstitutionally chilling to the concept of a free press
and certainly does nothing to alleviate the suspicions of many concerning
the possibility of a government cover-up."
December 10, 1997 The New York Times
The Clinton Administration is putting pressure on Pakistan -
"very strongly" in the words of one American
diplomat - to use its influence on the Taliban .... to get them to moderate
their behavior ..... The United States' major concerns in Afghanistan are
himan rights, drugs and terrorism .... Among the suspected terrorists living
in Kandahar, where the Taliban have their headquarters, is
Osama bin Ladin .... In a recent interview,
the Taliban Governor .... acknowledged that Mr. Ladin was there but answered
with a terse "No" when asked if he would
be handed over to the United States or any other government.
December 11, 1997 The New York Times
Federal safety investigators said Wednesday that they had found a frayed
wire from a fuel gauge in the tank that exploded on TWA Flight 800, leading
them to search for ways in which the wire -- combined with other problems
-- could have caused the explosion that took the lives of 230 people in July
1996. They said that the faulty wire could not
alone have caused the crash, since it normally carries less
electricity than needed to create a spark. But they said they were looking
into the possibility that problems with fuel tank wiring were part of
a series of failures that led to the
crash. In the third day of hearings into the crash of the Boeing 747 off
Long Island, investigators explored a variety of possible ignition sources
and delved deeply into fuel tank problems that Boeing and the Federal Aviation
Administration said were largely unexplored before the crash. One of these
is corrosion in the wiring in the tanks caused by sulfur in the fuel. The
chemical deposits that form around the gauges could provide the heat needed
for detonation if subjected to a surge of power. But
it is not clear where the surge would come
from; investigators said Wednesday that
some of the wiring that could have been a problem
had been found in good shape, and some had simply not been found.
A longstanding theory is that an electrical short-circuit somewhere else
in the plane sent a surge of power into what is supposed to be a low-voltage
system, although Boeing argues that there is no
system on board with enough power to do so. Wiring damage
and corrosion deposits could constitute "latent failures," or failures that
go undetected for months or years, and are of no importance until they combine
in unusual circumstances to cause an accident. They also represent a vast
expansion for government regulators of the problem of aging aircraft. ....
Investigators are focusing on corrosion and wiring damage partly because
an earlier theory, that a static charge had built
up inside the tank, has thus far been impossible to demonstrate in a
laboratory.
December 13, 1997 New York Times
A year and a half after 19 U.S. airmen were killed in Saudi Arabia, officials
have told their relatives they still do not know who carried out the truck
bombing of their barracks. Attorney General Janet Reno, FBI Director Louis
Freeh and other officials met privately with families of the victims of the
Khobar Towers bombing at a daylong counseling session and dinner Thursday
at which they promised to press on with the stalled investigation.
"There was great respect for us, but little
information," Fran Heiser, the mother of Master Sgt. Michael G.
Heiser, said Friday. "They don't have anything
concrete." The meeting, which was closed to the press and not
announced beforehand, was held at the FBI Academy at Quantico, Va. Mrs. Heiser,
who has been active in the efforts of the families to learn more about what
happened, said that members of 18 families attended. .... The airmen were
killed, and 500 other people wounded, when a large truck bomb exploded at
the housing complex near Dhahran for Air Force personnel mounting patrols
over the no-flight zone in southern Iraq declared after the Persian Gulf
War. ...... Investigators had hoped for a break when a
Saudi dissident, Hani Abdul Rahim Sayegh,
was arrested in Canada on information from Saudi intelligence that he drove
a scout car in the bombing. But Sayegh later reneged on a plea-bargain agreement
with U.S. officials to provide information, saying he only made it because
he feared execution if he was deported to Saudi Arabia. The Justice Department
case against him collapsed for lack of evidence. He is now in custody of
the immigration authorities, awaiting deportation hearings.
December 13, 1997 New York Times
The National Transportation Safety Board wound up
a week of hearings on the crash of Trans World Airlines Flight 800 Friday
without uncovering what made the plane explode shortly after takeoff, but
with something that its top officials say was almost as good: a consensus
that steps should be taken to cut the risk of fuel tank explosions in all
planes -- perhaps eliminating it entirely.
December 14, 1997 The New York Times
In 6,000 pages of documents and more than 35 hours of testimony presented
last week, dozens of aviation engineers and scientists laid out their analysis
of the explosion that destroyed Trans World Airlines Flight 800, seeking
to assign a cause to the catastrophe. And no one listened more carefully
during the National Transportation Safety Administration hearings than the
bevy of lawyers who are trying to assign blame for the crash more ..... Just
as the aviation investigators are seeking ways to guard against future fuel
tank explosions without knowing precisely what ignited the one on Flight
800, the lawyers are trying to assess liability despite this critical gap
in evidence. ..... The plaintiffs' lawyers and their aides studiously took
notes in laptop computers or on legal pads, sitting just behind the three
long sets of tables occupied by relatives of those who died. In the final
hours of the hearing, the meeting halls became a hive of discussions and
strategy sessions as lawyers, victims' relatives and officials of TWA and
Boeing girded for would could be years of legal and financial wrangling.
.... there is the challenge of proving a case for a particular cause of the
crash. Several aviation lawyers who have represented airlines in similar
lawsuits said that the absence of clues to what ignited the blast in the
center fuel tank on Flight 800, which has proved exasperating to investigators,
may also prove so to lawyers for the families as they try to build convincing
cases. "It's a basic concept from Law 101: the party
with the burden of proof has got to prove something," said Bonnie
Cohen, a lawyer from San Francisco who for more than 15 years has represented
airlines in suits resulting from plane crashes. ...... But Lee S. Kreindler,
a Manhattan lawyer whose firm is representing families of 80 of the 230 victims,
says the case is as basic as the ancient phrase
of law: Res ipsa loquitur. The thing speaks for itself. The Boeing 747 exploded
when one of many potential sources of a spark ignited fuel vapor in its
overheated center fuel tank. Given those facts, the case is "garden-variety
product liability," Kreindler said. .... Frank H. Granito Jr.,
a Manhattan lawyer whose firm is representing the families of 54 victims,
said the hearings also provided a kind of casting call for witnesses. He
and the other lawyers were able to observe the style and communications skills
of dozens of experts, many of whom might be called to testify in coming liability
and damage trials. .... Another potential problem, said Granito, the Manhattan
lawyer, could be trying to find a jury that did not have at least a few members
who still believed that a bomb, missile or perhaps even a meteorite could
have destroyed the plane. The FBI has decided that there was no evidence
that a criminal act caused the crash, and all manner of experts testified
that the evidence makes a bomb, missile or meteorite almost impossible.
Even so, Granito said, he would try to persuade
Judge Robert W. Sweet, who is handling the cases in U.S. District Court in
Manhattan, to prevent the companies from reviving these theories.
A hearing will be held next Tuesday before Sweet. ..... And as the hearings
continued, the lawyers continued to collect more bits of evidence suggesting
hidden hazards in the giant jets. Particularly significant, the lawyers said,
was Boeing's concession that it needed a new approach to preventing such
explosions, saying that the 40-year-old design philosophy for fuel tanks
on airliners -- focused on eliminating sparks -- needed to be augmented by
a search for ways to get rid of flammable vapors.
"That's just another way of saying their plane's
defective," Kreindler said. He said the findings reported at the
hearing provided a telling road map. Referring to photographs of frayed wires
and tests showing that fuel vapors would have been overheated and highly
flammable, he said: "They're not talking about theory
here. We can prove this stuff has happened. This is no different than tobacco
or a bad car. We can prove they made an unsafe product."
December 15, 1997 The New York Times
President Mohammed Khatami of Iran aimed a conciliatory message at the United
States on Sunday, saying that he hoped to re-establish a discussion with
the American people that has been virtually suspended since the Islamic
revolution of 1979. The tone of Khatami's remarks, his first news conference
since he took office in August, was markedly different from that usually
heard from Iranian leaders. He declared "great
respect" for the "great people of the
United States" and even his criticism of the government in Washington,
which he said stood in the way of possible reconciliation, was restrained.
"I hope the American politicians would understand
their time better, understand the realities, and move forward,"
Khatami said. At the "appropriate" time, he said,
"I will present my words to the American people."
"I would hope for a thoughtful dialogue with the American people and through
this thoughtful dialogue we could get closer to peace and security and
tranquillity," he added. ...... In Washington, a State Department
spokesman, James Foley, cautioned that "it's too
early to tell whether this represents an offer or not." He said
the United States has been "open to a
dialogue" with Iran, but has "stipulated
that the dialogue would have to be official and authoritiative, acknowledged
publicly by the Iranian government." If such a dialogue occurred,
Foley said: "We would certainly be raising with
the Iranians our concern about aspects of their foreign policy which are
deeply troubling to us, concerning weapons of mass destruction and terrorism
and the like. But we are open to a dialogue and would expect they could raise
issues of concern to them as well."...
"Instead of talking with forked tongues we want
to have a rational dialogue," Khatami said.
"We want to have a dialogue of
civilizations." Khatami's message might help to mute American
objections to closer ties with Iran, but there was little in what he had
to say that appeared sufficient to allay what have been the United States'
principal concerns. He did not address allegations that the Iran is attempting
to acquire nuclear weapons, a charge that his country has repeatedly denied
in the past. He said Iran was opposed to terrorism,
but made an exception for "the legitimate defense of people in occupied land,"
thus offering an implicit justification of Iran's support for Hezbollah and
other militant groups fighting against Israeli occupation.
December 15, 1997 The New York Times
For several months, in low-key meetings at the United Nations that began
after Mohammed Khatami took office in August as Iran's first popularly elected
president, Iranians and Americans have been working
together in a small group of interested nations to explore ways to end the
civil war in Afghanistan. ... "We are hopeful that the Iranians
will play a constructive role in bringing their influence to bear to see
the fighting stop and negotiations begin for the establishment of a broad-based
government in Afghanistan," said Karl F. Inderfurth, assistant secretary
of state for South Asian affairs and the American official who has been meeting
with the Iranians in New York.
December 15, 1997 Aviation Week and Space
Technology
NTSB efforts to elicit potentially vital information
from witnesses to the flight and crash of TWA Flight 800 were stymied for
months by FBI agents who blocked any attempts to interview the
witnesses, according to a copy of a safety board report obtained
by Aviation Week & Space Technology. The witnesses
included .... 96 ... witnesses who claimed to have seen a streak of light
rise from the surface prior to the 747-131's crash. ...... Two
days after the July 17, 1996, crash, as the witness group was preparing to
start interviewing witnesses, an FBI agent informed NTSB officials that the
bureau "was not prepared to share any information
outside the NTSB, so parties [to the safety board investigation] could not
be involved," the witness group report states. The NTSB had named
one of its investigators, Bruce Magladry, to head the witness group, which
initially included representatives of TWA, the Air Line Pilots Assn. and
the FAA. On July 21, 1996, the report states, Assistant U.S. Attorney Valerie
Caproni informed Magladry and Norm Wiemeyer, head of the Flight 800 probe's
operations group, "that no interviews were to be
conducted by the NTSB." Safety board investigators could review
FBI-supplied documents on the witnesses, "provided
no notes were taken and no copies were made." The next day, FBI
and NTSB officials reached an agreement that safety board officials could
conduct interviews "under the direction and in the
company of the FBI, and all information would be kept private with no notes
taken." Concerned that this interfered with the NTSB's mandate
to make public the information gathered in its investigations,
Magladry withdrew from the witness group two days
later. The NTSB's efforts to glean information from witnesses
did not resume until mid-November 1996. The new witness group was made up
of representatives of the NTSB, TWA, ALPA and the FAA, as well as Boeing,
the International Federation of Flight Attendants and International Assn.
of Machinists. It was then that the FBI permitted the group members to review
notes of interviews with witnesses (26 of whom were airborne when they observed
the crash) and service, maintenance and cargo personnel from New York's John
F. Kennedy International Airport and the airport in Athens. ... It was not
until mid-January that the group members interviewed New York Air National
Guard personnel who were on duty the night of the crash, including the HH-60
and C-130 crews operating in the area (AW&ST Mar. 10, p. 35). ...
The report said there were 458 witness interviews
provided by the FBI. Of those, 183 reported seeing a streak of light and
102 provided information on the origin of the streak. The report stated that
six witnesses said the streak originated in the sky and
96 said it rose from the
surface. It is not clear whether the accounts of the 96 witnesses
were included in the 244 analyzed by the CIA for the FBI.
The analysts concluded that the witnesses did not
see a missile strike Flight 800.
December 16, 1997 Reuters
Lawyers defending TWA and Boeing against suits over the Flight 800 explosion
told a judge on Tuesday they were asking federal authorities to share their
data on whether a missile or bomb could have caused the crash. The FBI has
decided there was no evidence that a criminal act caused the disaster, but
a lawyer for Boeing Co. said the defendants still wanted to review information
gathered by the FBI and the National Transportation Safety Board.
The lawyer, Steven Bell of Seattle, said that
authorities have denied TWA and Boeing access to the data so far.
He said that the information could be relevant to the defense.
"It's something we have to assess," ...
U.S. District Judge Robert Sweet told the lawyers that since the probe was
not officially closed, he doubted that the request would be successful. .....
Lee Kreindler, a lawyer whose firm is representing about 80 families, said
he expected the missile and bomb theories would eventually be removed from
the case. "If that is an issue in the case, we have
everything introduced in Baltimore. There's a lot of hard evidence on our
side," he said. The hearing on the matter was set for March 4.
December 16, 1997 The Associated Press
TWA and Boeing asked a judge Tuesday to help them get evidence from the criminal
investigation into the TWA Flight 800 explosion, including statements from
people who thought they saw a missile near the plane. The lawyers made the
appeal to U.S. District Judge Robert W. Sweet during a routine pretrial hearing
in the case brought by some of the families of 230 people who died in the
July 17, 1996 disaster. Steve Bell, a Boeing lawyer,
said the companies had been denied evidence relating to the criminal
investigation by the FBI and the National Transportation Safety
Board. Sweet said he would wait to consider intervening until
it was clear exactly what evidence the lawyers believed was relevant. .....
Bell said evidence that could show a jury that a bomb or missile may have
caused the disaster was "obviously relevant. It
means somebody else is responsible, not Boeing," he said.
December 23, 1997 The Associated Press
An FBI agent who early in his career posed as the head of dummy companies
in the undercover ABSCAM operation was named Tuesday to head the agency's
criminal division as an assistant director. The announcement by FBI Director
Louis J. Freeh elevates Thomas J. Pickard
from head of the bureau's Washington field office to its No. 3
post. Freeh noted that Pickard, 47, played a primary
role in the investigation of the crash of TWA Flight 800 and helped
personally take two terrorist suspects who were in foreign countries into
U.S. custody. He also supervised the FBI's role in the trials of four World
Trade Center bombing defendants and Sheik Omar
Abdel-Rahman, a blind cleric convicted in 1995 of conspiring with
nine others to blow up the United Nations headquarters and other New York
City landmarks. ..... In an interview, Pickard said computer technology
and the opportunities it gives criminals to commit fraud poses one of the
greatest challenges to the FBI. "When I started
in the FBI, I used to jump over fences and chase fugitives and bank robbers
and white-collar criminals through the back yards,'' Pickard said.
"Now the new young agents are jumping over fences
and jumping into cyberspace. ...Pickard recalled that as a young
agent he posed as the head of two "cover companies'' the FBI set up in 1979
to offer money to politicians in return for helping other agents posing as
Middle East businessmen get immigration papers to stay in this country.....ABSCAM
resulted in convictions of several members of Congress.
The FBI was criticized by a Senate committee for
not properly supervising the investigation and targeting some officials without
evidence they were predisposed to take bribes.
December 24, 1997 The York Times
Denver, Dec. 23 -
Terry L. Nichols was convicted today of conspiring
to bomb the Oklahoma City Federal Building, but in a nuanced verdict, a Federal
... jury acquitted him of ... committing .. the worst terrorist act on United
States soil.